H
Hardcover
Voters
J
J
B
W
M
+12
Powered by Noora
17
Add privacy levels for personal stats
J
Jet Silver
Sep 22, 2026

Currently any user can view any other user's full stats page. Can we have granular control here to show full (or partial if that's a future option) stats to a) everyone/public b) logged in users c) mutual followers d) private/no one

Full reading history and patterns being accessible like this is more data for a person's digital footprint and we should have the option of locking it down.

Comments
A
Adam
Oct 7, 2026

Just a heads up on this - the stats page only shows you what you can see.

We effectively have three versions of the stats page:

Private: The one you see, with everything
Following: The one people you follow can see
Public: The one everyone else sees.

The page itself is still visible, but the content on it will be derived from the books that you've allowed the viewing user to view.

Does that already solve this?

0
M
Merry
Oct 18, 2026

Adam No. There are no options for a ‘users only’ privacy level. I’ve taken a hiatus from HC bc of it.

0
A
Adam
Oct 18, 2026

Merry Can you say more about this? What would you ideally want to see for privacy? 🤔

0
J
Jet Silver
Nov 6, 2026

Adam Are you saying that there are different privacy levels Lifetime stats pages already available?

Or are you saying that because the user has marked the individual books included in their stats as public or private you feel that this solves the feature request?

If so: no it doesn't. Aggregate data is more sensitive than individual pieces of that data. To put it in another context, a person might be comfortable saying they've visited several locations, but that doesn't mean they want to publish their full Google Maps location history page.

PS I didn't get an email as I usually would when someone replies to the thread - are emails still working?

0
A
Adam
Nov 13, 2026

Hmm, the way this is designed is that no aggregate data, other than lifetime books count, which is global to the user and shows in the header of the users profile page, are public data for a user (as it's designed right now). The aggregate data on the stats page is scoped to what the user viewing the stats page can see.

So if someone has all private books in their library, then the stats page should show zero books read when not logged in.

There's a similar setup for the stats page if you have "follows only" books - where unless the user viewing your page is someone you follow, they'd also see zero books here.

(not sure on the emails - I'll have to check on that. I did get an email about this comment though).

0
J
Jet Silver
Nov 14, 2026

Adam What I'm saying is I don't want to display my lifetime stats page to anyone. It's not the number read, that's whatever. It's the years read graphs that show age, it's the grouped topics that show interests over time, the publication data that suggests user location.

I am happy to have each individual book public and hide a couple I don't want public. I want to share each book with the community and use HC as a community site.

But the level of easy data mining enabled by the lifetime stats page is something I don't want. If you want me to explain further why lifetime data in one place is different than the same data across thousands of book pages I will, but I hoped the maps timeline example would illustrate.

I don't want my only solution to this to be effectively, use the site privately and forego community.

Or maybe I'm misunderstanding you?

I didn't get an email about you reply here, just fwiw.

0
H
Hardcover Team
Nov 14, 2026

Jet Silver Ohh, that was helpful! You want to have public books, and also be able to have private stats. I understand now. 👍

1
J
Jet Silver
Nov 15, 2026

Hardcover Team

Thanks for continuing to engage! Yes, that's what I wanted to ask for.

Also to reiterate the missing privacy levels that would be super useful.

  1. Public (anyone with the link)
  2. Logged in HC accounts (any user, currently missing)
  3. Mutual Followers only or a new Friend level (this means the user gets to approve access by a new account)
  4. Private (no one but the OP)

I did get an email for your latest reply, thanks for the fix.

0
M
Merry
Sep 30, 2026

Commenting to strongly support this; requested increased privacy features in June but was a bit narrow so the suggestion has been bumped away.

With AI agents increasingly in the news, being able to have greater control over our privacy seems more pertinent than ever. I don’t want my data to be followers-only, but I also don’t want it to train a roaming LLM.

2